- 1859 James Stirrat
- 1860 James Stirrat
- 1861 James Stirrat
- 1862 James Stirrat
- 1863 James Stirrat
- 1864 Michael Miller
- 1865 Michael Miller
- 1866 John McCron
- 1867 George R Coffroth * 1880
- 1868 Emanual Corbett
- 1869 Emanual Corbett
- 1870 Hiram Musselman
- 1871 Frank J Kugler
- 1872 Frank J Kugler
- 1873 William T Adreon
- 1874 Richard D Murphy
- 1875 J Henry Weber
- 1876 J Henry Weber
- 1877 Henry O Reese * 1890
- 1878 John S Tyson
- 1879 William H Clark
- 1880 J A Charles Kahler * 1887
- 1881 William C Oppelt
- 1882 R H Conway
- 1883 Thomas McCourbray Jr
- 1884 H H Garrigues
- 1885 William C Nickum
- 1886 George W Starr Jr
- 1887 J Frank Wilhelm
- 1888 William K Klinesmith
- 1889 George Cook * 1896
- 1890 Thomas F Sprigg
- 1891 Mark A Clift
- 1892 George L Sollers
- 1893 Henry C Larrabee
- 1894 George W Hussell
- 1895 Theodore Sumwalt
- 1896 C Henry Bischoff
- 1897 George R Kinsey
- 1898 John F Yewell
- 1899 William Rigor
- 1900 Daniel J Emich * 1905
- 1901 Harry A Remley * 1911
- 1902 Edwin J Griffin *1917
- 1903 Joseph A Sessions
- 1904 Alexander P Bayliss
- 1905 George T Phillips
- 1906 George T Phillips
- 1907 John M Naill
- 1908 Leonard J Wilson
- 1909 Charles E Franck
- 1910 Samuel O Randall
- 1911 Warren S Seipp * 1922
- 1912 Charles H Burns
- 1913 Charles W Grant
- 1914 August C Weber
- 1915 Albert C Wroten
- 1916 Henry M Nitzel
- 1917 George A Smith
- 1918 Conrad Bernhard Jr
- 1919 Edward S White
- 1920 Herman Laske
- 1921 James F Argabright
- 1922 James W Bueschel
- 1923 Chester A Warren
- 1924 Charles S Davis
- 1925 Joseph H Poats?
- 1926 Charles W Geizer?
- 1927 Thomas Butterworth
- 1928 John I Waters
- 1929 Schuyler C Blackburn * 1943
- 1930 Thomas B Sprague?
- 1931 Martin J Gladwell / Chadwell?
- 1932 William B Matthews
- 1933 Anders Randrup
- 1934 J Edward Collins
- 1935 W Samuel Parks
- 1936 J Emery M Carpenter
- 1937 Charles W Chamberlain Jr
- 1938 Raymond L Maloney
- 1939 Holland E Miller
- 1940 Gilbert L Pickering
April 1941, Baltimore Commandery No. 2, K. T. merges with Maryland Commandery No. 1, K. T.
Records available start in 1890 (see 1890 fire). Found a 50 year anniversary program from 1909 that listed all the Past Commanders.
* Grand Commander of Knights Templar of the State of Maryland
^ Grand Master of Masons in Maryland